12 minute read

AI Has No Story to Tell

AI Has No Story to Tell

Pre-emptively trying to establish one’s own mythicness has consequences — including potentially ending up with no story. Explore the four problems facing AI’s narrative absence and what its creators will have to give up in order to successfully market this technology.

Pre-emptively trying to establish one’s own mythicness has consequences — including potentially ending up with no story. Explore the four problems facing AI’s narrative absence and what its creators will have to give up in order to successfully market this technology.

Victoria Gamlen

Victoria Gamlen

Not everyone is buying tech’s claims about AI — what it offers today or what it promises for the future. Within the industry and among AI’s advocates, the diagnosis is a storytelling and communications problem.

While it's best not to lead with how many jobs it's going to take or vague threats of mass casualties when trying to get people to adopt a new technology, the pushback to the AI narrative goes deeper than these pronouncements.

At the core of the diagnosis lies the belief that storytelling is simply the spinning of tales, and that if you manipulate language just so, people will buy what you are selling. 

But a story is not simply declared into existence — it’s the result of a specific structural process:

Contact with reality that produces friction through constraints or consequences that strips away what is false while creating a new form that both possesses weight and can withstand pressure.

What emerges in the context of storytelling for marketing purposes is a truth about what those claims amount to in practice that resonates with the intended target audience: what becomes possible, for whom, under what conditions, and to what degree.

Storytelling itself is then simply the scaling of that truth. 

Despite a misguided definition of storytelling, tech’s assertion that AI as a technology and has a storytelling problem is, however, correct. 

They’ve just failed to consider that the problem is that there simply isn’t one to tell — and there are four main reasons why.

The Campbellian Problem

When it comes to AI, the tech industry is mistaking a distribution event (a general-purpose capability becoming more widely available and used) for a mythic-level and civilizational-grade event (a specific transformation that produces a new symbolic order, a new protagonist, and a credible return on a worldwide scale).

It is essentially trying to force the byproduct of what Joseph Campbell would refer to as the hero’s journey onto the world without the actual journey.¹

A writer and professor of literature whose most notable work centered around comparative mythology,² Campbell studied recurring symbols, themes, and narrative patterns in myths from different cultures.

All 17 steps of the journey are shown in the image below. Here is a summary of the most critical parts:

  • Myth organizes a passage through rupture.

  • A prior world is separated from.

  • The old identity or order loses its sufficiency.

  • A threshold is crossed.

  • The protagonist is altered.

  • Something is returned that renews a community or world.

In his seminal work, The Hero with a Thousand Faces, he describes the first step, “The Call to Adventure,” as follows:

“The familiar life horizon has been outgrown; the old concepts, ideals, and emotional patterns no longer fit; the time for the passing of a threshold is at hand.”³

In Campbellian terms, a creation becomes mythically consequential when it answers a genuine rupture (i.e., failure) between an inherited or previous order and a lived reality where something can no longer be answered or achieved by the arrangements, practices, or meanings people have typically leveraged or referenced — or in this case, the tools or technology. 

The issue with tech’s positioning of AI as the byproduct of a mythic transformation is that there was no rupture. 

Something taking time is not evidence of a failed order. It is an inherent part of creation — whether it’s a mother’s body making a human, a house taking time to build, or an email taking time to write.

The fact that something can now be done faster does not mean the world was waiting to be rescued from doing it more slowly.

Neither is a task requiring effort, expertise, or another person a symptom of a broken world. You can make something easier without demonstrating that the difficulty was intolerable or a waste.

The need to possess a skill to successfully achieve an objective is not a form of gatekeeping or elitism that must be overcome in order for equality to be realized. Treating the unavoidable requirement of effort and time to learn something as a moral offense is nothing more than a lazy Nietzschean inversion.

And being able to do something that was previously impossible does not mean that its impossibility made the old world untenable.

Whether or not a new capability exceeds a previous limit is irrelevant. What matters in the context of a mythic transformation is whether that limit had made the old world unlivable or inadequate.

“We developed a powerful technology” doesn’t become “we delivered humanity into a new order” just because the creators of the technology want it to. 

There is a useful technology here, I am not denying that. But that does not mean there was a failed world awaiting its arrival.

Tech’s framing of AI works backward from the capability: because we can now remove this effort, the effort must have been an obstacle humanity needed to overcome. Because we can generate the result instantly, the time previously spent producing it must have been time lost.

But the existence of a quicker path or process does not retrospectively turn the longer route into a catastrophe.

Tech has mistaken the existence of a shortcut for evidence that humanity was lost; “now we can” is being treated as proof that “we needed to.” 

There’s a difference between “this can help you do something” and “this rescues you from the conditions under which you previously did it.” The first offers a tool, the second provides a noble role for its maker.

And a genuine benefit still doesn’t automatically justify the scale of the story. You can solve a problem without resolving a civilizational crisis. You can improve someone’s day without delivering them into a new symbolic order. There is nothing deficient about that — unless the creators really need to be viewed as a savior.

The tech industry has cast AI as the answer to a failure of the old world without establishing what failed.

There was no necessary departure and no journey through which a new order is earned. There is only a technology being distributed as though its arrival were the return of a hero.

By trying to tell the story of a return — with what Campbell calls the “boon,” the recognition, the glory — without establishing why anyone needed to leave, tech is claiming the conclusion of a transformation that never took place.

Without the rupture, there is no journey. Without the journey, the story that the arrival of this technology is a hero that ushers humanity into a new era doesn’t exist — even if the arrival of this technology is, in fact, changing the world.

The Ubiquity Problem

At the same time they’re mistaking a distribution event for a mythic event, tech is also trying to tell a story where the distribution event of AI — meaning where AI becomes ambient, and indispensable — is a mythic force in the more commonly used form of the word, meaning legendary and awe-inspiring. 

This is slightly different to the Campbellian problem above in that it’s not so much mistaking one thing for another as trying to slot AI into two contradictory positions at once.

It wants the byproduct and end state of the hero’s journey without having gone on it because the conditions don’t exist for a journey to occur, while still being able to claim the ordinariness of infrastructure.

But ubiquity and myth cannot coexist; the two are at odds. 

Now, ubiquitous things can participate in myth. Electricity, cars, railways, television, and the Internet were mythic when they reorganized social life or opened up genuinely new possibilities. 

But once a technology becomes general infrastructure, it can no longer be “this magical, life-changing new thing”; it must forfeit its mythic status in order to provide the backdrop in which specific brands can then bring forth mythic stories. 

Running shoes weren’t a new concept; Nike told a mythic story. Denim was just a common workwear fabric; Levi’s told a mythic story. Cigarettes were a commodity; Marlboro told a mythic story. 

The more ambient a technology or tool becomes, the less “story” is available because general-purpose technologies cannot remain permanent protagonists. 

It goes from main character to backstage hand — still necessary, just not the star of the show.

The tech industry currently wants AI to occupy both positions at once: the backdrop against which everything happens and the extraordinary event around which everything revolves. Its promoters want its presence to become unremarkable while insisting that its presence is the remarkable story.

This contradiction creates a gridlock in the story creation process from which no story can come forth.

The Marketing Problem

Effective marketing requires a deep understanding of the problem you’re solving and/or your target audience. Because when it comes to marketing, you are really only ever selling four things:

  1. A solution to a problem

  2. A transformation

  3. An experience / feeling

  4. An identity

Most entities leverage a combination of these things, with options three and four typically being reserved as options for luxury industries. 

All four hinge on desire: whether that’s a desire to solve a problem (which isn’t a guarantee), the desire to change, the desire to experience something, or the desire to be perceived a certain way. 

Many will argue that desire has no place in B2B SaaS and that demand can’t be generated if it doesn’t already exist.

But these same people can’t seem to explain how a billion-dollar marketing analytics industry that successfully generated demand for outrageously expensive dashboards and intent data that shows you everything except what’s working in your marketing. (Hint: they did so by tapping into the desire of struggling marketers desiring to be seen as responsible and data-driven.)

And with CEOs cutting 10%+ of their workforce to go “all in” on a nascent technology that’s prone to errors as a way to appear forward-thinking and innovative, I would say that AI has successfully sold identity as well to many executives.

But much of these purchasing decisions were also driven by FOMO, and fear only works for so long before an absence of ROI on an investment of that size with promises that sensational overrides it. 

Similarly, just like story creation, effective marketing messaging in B2B requires contact with reality that produces a specific outcome. But those outcomes haven't come to fruition yet.

So the industry has been relying heavily on claims of intangible, open-ended future states:

  • Capability claims: “anything is possible.”

  • Category claims: “every company will become an AI company.”

  • Anthropomorphic claims: “your intelligent teammate/copilot/agent.”

  • Civilizational claims: “the next platform shift.”

These claims describe the significance the industry AI wants to have, not its relevance to the audience. 

But it takes two parties to tell a story: one party to tell it, and one to care. And relevance for the audience requires specificity. Without specificity, there is no “weight” to the story. Like air, it can neither make an impact nor withstand pressure because it is not dense enough to make an impact nor hold meaning.

This missing weight becomes especially apparent when the audience is consumers rather than businesses. 

Desire, nor emotions, are "created" — both can only ever be tapped into. 

The desire to solve the problems that consumer AI claims to solve does not exist for many consumers, because many consumers do not see things as problems; not everyone is trying to optimize themselves out of the human experience.

The threat of “getting left behind” doesn’t work on an indifferent audience, and to the anti-AI crowd, it’s a welcome promise.

For many consumers, AI is simply a solution in search of a problem, a pattern that is a hallmark trait of tech that I first wrote about over three years ago. 

Removing effort is not the same as solving a problem. The effort has to be something the audience wants removed.

Where there is no problem the audience wants solved, the product needs a compelling account of what else it offers: a transformation, an experience or feeling, or an identity.

Transformation, like story and myth, requires contact with reality (friction) that produces a new form, an experience requires participation, and the production of a feeling requires a process that produces a chemical reaction through doing. Identity formation also requires contact with reality to produce a new form. 

But the entire premise of AI is that it exists to remove friction, participation, and the creation process, the very mechanism by which transformation occurs, an experience is had, a feeling is produced, or an identity is formed. 

Which means there is technically no marketing story or messaging for AI as a technology.

The Entitlement Problem

The year is around 546 BCE. Croesus, king of Lydia in Western Anatolia, is debating whether or not to invade Persia and reclaim certain territories after Cyrus II’s growing power began threatening the regional balance.

To help him decide, he sends envoys to the oracles at Delphi three times to consult with them on the matter. The first time is to establish if he can trust them (they pass). The second time is to find out if he should attack Persia. Both priestesses respond that “if he should send an army against the Persians he would destroy a great empire.”⁴ Croesus assumes they are referring to the Persians and he is pleased. 

The third envoy is sent to ask if his monarchy will last. The priestess Loxias responds: 

"Lydian, beware of the day when a mule is lord of the Medians:

Then with thy delicate feet by the stone-strewn channel of Hermus

Flee for thy life, nor abide, nor blush for the name of a craven."⁵

Croesus assumes this meant his downfall was impossible since an animal could not possibly rule a kingdom, and thus, he was pleased again. 

He attacks the district of Pteria in Cappadocia (a territory under Persian control), capturing its main city, enslaving its inhabitants, and ravaging the surrounding settlements. 

Cyrus arrives and they fight an inconclusive battle. Croesus is captured and taken prisoner and ordered to be burned. He prays to Apollo, it starts raining, and the fire is put out. His life is spared, his empire is not.  

Shocked by this series of events, Croesus sends an envoy back to Delphi to complain to the priestesses about their inaccurate prophecy.

One of the priestesses replies that it’s not the oracles’ fault that Croesus asked no follow-up questions regarding which empire would be destroyed, and that he failed to recognize “mule” in its figurative sense of someone of mixed parentage⁶  — in this case Cyrus — not a metaphor for an impossible situation.⁷

Tech is facing a similar situation today — except there is zero ambiguity or riddles to decipher. 

People have made their priorities clear through purchasing decisions — not just by voicing opinions on Twitter — that, as of this moment in time, that the story being told about AI by the tech industry is not true for them in terms of the technology’s usefulness, power, or relevance to their lives.⁸

Instead of getting curious and examining the gap between what they’re promising and what people are experiencing, responses from the tech industry range from the following: 

  • “This AI doomerism makes me so sad, the future could be so bright,” (with zero insight as to how).

  • “All they’ve seen is slop, so that’s what they associate with AI,” (correct).

  • Basically calling anyone with skepticism about an AI-filled future that awaits a Luddite retard that’s going to die alone with the Amish (not hyperbole).

There are literally drug dealers with more respect for their target audience.

Except, AI is getting implemented. People are using it. Sometimes because they have no other choice (e.g., AI overviews and chatbots). But AI adoption is happening.

And that’s what makes this specific brand of butt hurted-ness with its three-in-one energetic signature of the puer aeternus⁹ through the focus on possibility over reality and desiring recognition of one’s specialness, a resentful unappreciated mother through the expectation of gratitude, and the aggrieved child that demands unconditional love so interesting. 

Implementation isn’t enough, it must be accompanied by admiration and reverence. People are not simply being asked to use a technology; they are being asked to affirm the heroic story told about it.

And this brings us back to the mythic journey. 

Campbell explicitly acknowledges in the chapter covering The Crossing of the Return Threshold that not all mythic transformations or “boons” are accepted once the hero must face the community again (in this case, the hero being AI), when he writes: 

“He has yet to confront society with his ego-shattering, life-redeeming elixir, and take the return blow of reasonable queries, hard resentment, and good people at a loss to comprehend. [That] is the hero’s ultimate difficult task. How to render back into light-world language the speech-defying pronouncements of the dark?”¹⁰

So they not only feel entitled to a heroic outcome without submitting to the journey, but they also want to be exempt from the outcome’s unpleasant consequences — a tough spot indeed. 

Where to From Here?

It is unlikely that the tech industry will ever recover its reputation after the last year of rhetoric choices from leaders at AI companies, the fearmongering and hostility of the pro-AI crowd on social media, and the fact that this technology is unfortunately both taking people’s jobs and causing people to lose them.

However, the technology is clearly not going anywhere and it can be incredibly useful for a variety of things. 

None of these things negate one another; they can all be true at once. 

With regards to storytelling, the imposition and insistence of a heroic sequence on something whose use does not constitute a heroic journey is preventing the tech industry from actually finding a story that might resonate with those who remain unconvinced about AI.

The journey is being reverse-engineered from the desired ending. The creators want to return as heroes, so ordinary life has to be recast as the ordeal from which they have delivered everyone.

And if people don’t experience their lives that way — if they don’t regard writing an email, planning a holiday, or making something themselves as evidence that their world has failed — then it is actually framing of the story that is failing. 

The industry must make a choice: 

Forego a colossal, shapeless myth — as well as being viewed as some type of salvific force — and double down on utility and specificity; not one broad, sweeping story about AI transforming humanity, but many stories grounded in particular experiences. Or keep trying to force something that is a structural impossibility and continue to face resistance and dig the hole they’re already in further into the ground. 

Tech is under the impression that if they just come up with the right combination of words, in the right order, to describe this technology, it can supersede people’s experience of it and they will form a different opinion of it.

But that’s not how storytelling works. Storytelling is the scaling of a truth that emerges after contact with reality. The truth the industry is attempting to scale is not recognized as true by its intended audience.

Therefore, no story currently exists.

If society’s transformation has already been declared, people’s refusal to validate and consider it some type of deliverance from some type of rupture will always be considered a “storytelling problem.”

The problem is not that the storyteller cannot find a flattering account. It is that the tech industry has already decided which account it will accept.

If the experience of a technology contradicts what was promised, the promise should change. Instead, the brief changes: find a better way to tell it.

Because revising the promise would require admitting that maybe the entire industry got the whole AI thing wrong. 

And for an industry whose entire existence is based on an obsession with certainty and control, it seems that admitting it is the one thing tech seems unwilling to do.

Sources & Footnotes

We provide website planning, UX design, UI design, and responsive page design tailored to your brand and business goals. Depending on the project, development and ongoing support can also be included. You can choose only the services you need.

Deviation Standard is a publication by Victoria Gamlen. She is the founder of Gamlen Consulting, an identity advisory firm for growth-stage companies focused on the internal architecture required to withstand the realities of scaling through audits, workshops, and 1:1 consulting sessions.

Deviation Standard

©2026 Victoria Gamlen. All rights reserved.